Grille d'évaluation
Conditions d’achèvement
| Item évalué
|
Points
|
Critères |
|---|---|---|
| Front page
|
2 | Perfect / Titre & Abstract OK / None OK
|
| Structure
|
2 | Structure IMRD* / MD only / none
|
| Figure quality
|
2 | Vector format / appropriate resolution / inappropriate resolution
|
| Figure legend
|
2 | Self consistent figures / Appropriate legend / No legend
|
| Figure numbering
|
1 | Numbered figure / not numbered figures
|
| Figure placement
|
1 | Figure adequately placed on page top, page bottom or page middle / Figures break text
|
| English
|
2 | Scientific English / Everyday English / Bad English
|
| Is individual work properly identified ?
|
1 | Individual work or properly attributed work / several authors and unattributed work
|
| References
|
3 | Journal like / perfect references / references with defects / no references
|
| Reference citations
|
2 | Journal like citations / citations done but badly placed / no citations
|
| Scientific soundness
|
1 | Is the paper scientifically sound ?
|
| Look
|
1 | Does the paper look good ? Would I read it ?
|
*IMRD : Introduction Methods Results Discussion
Modifié le: jeudi 19 janvier 2023, 08:20